indiana hiker wrote:Hey Pete, I ordered the Osprey Talon (from Backcountry) right after you mentioned it in April. Haven't used it yet, but some reviews note the waist strap as being too thin. What did you think? Just trying it around the house, seemed ok, but didn't have any water or supplies in it.
Yeah, I saw that criticism about the waist band being too thin, and therefore uncomfortable.
Beginning with the general proposition that:
No pack will fit comfortably on every person
And given that any pack can be uncomfortable on any given person(no different than boots/shoes, or anything else "personal")...
In my opinion, most of those complaints regarding the waist belt cutting into them come from:
1) overloading the pack and/or...
2) from people who are "overweight".
I weighed mine after seeing your post. Refilled the bottles(which I do not like because they won't stand up. Those were a DUMB design)
Just over 4 lbs. Other than the ~1liter of water, I had a light windbreaker, two energy bars, Sony P&S camera. GPS and wallet in pants pocket.
Never felt the weight while walking. Loosen the belt a bit and slide the pack around to reach water and camera.
IMO, this pack is
not made to haul a lot of weight. I got mine to do short(ish) hikes on GOOD weather days like ShangriLa, the Dragon's Tail, Scenic point, etc.
Then if I'm carrying my A77II, it will carry more comfortably than if I was wearing a backpack.
Some people believe that because a pack has pockets, they all need to be stuffed full of "something"
Fine with me,
be uncomfortable.
I measured the "tag end" you pull on to tighten the belt. After i got in on around my waist(34"W, 34"inseam---6'4"/182lbs) where I wear it(right over belly button)...
The loose ends were each 8 inches.
More important, the padded hip portion of the belt ended just above my
hip bone.
The pack weight is held snug against my back
above my waistline, where it should be.
And I don't
overload the pack, and so it is less prone to "sag", pulling at my stomach in front.
The larger one's waist line is, the more of that thin belt will be let out.
That in turn places the body of the pack in a position to sag over your butt....
Since the "hip belt" is no longer properly situated over your hips.
And the tighter you pull the belt to try and get the pack up where it's supposed to be, the more it cuts into your mid section.
I don't doubt it's uncomfortable for some people.
Bottom line for me is that one needs to find a fanny pack design that fits ones body properly.
Get that weight, whatever it is, distributed on ones hips. It'll make a HUGE difference in comfort over a long day.
I have a Marmot fanny pack for heavier loads. Big wide, tall lumbar pad in back. Wider waist belt.
I used it last year summiting Piegan---on a very nice day.
Way more comfortable than a back pack for lighter loads imo.
pete